Lump sum or dollar-cost averaging? A worked example
When prices are falling, spreading looks smart, and when they rise it looks silly. The numbers behind the choice.
If you have money to invest in a falling market, you can invest it all now or in equal parts over time (dollar-cost averaging). This post compares them with invented numbers. It is not advice.
An invented example
Alex has $6,000. The price per share today is $10.
- Lump sum: $6,000 buys 600 shares.
- Six monthly payments of $1,000 at $10, $8, $7, $8, $9 and $10: 100, 125, 142.9, 125, 111.1 and 100 shares, so 704. A fall then a recovery favored spreading.
- If prices only rise ($10, $11, $12, $13, $14, $15): 100, 90.9, 83.3, 76.9, 71.4 and 66.7 shares, so 489, and the lump sum (600 shares) wins.
Which method wins depends on what the market does next, which no one knows in advance.
What research found
A well-known Vanguard research paper found that, across the markets it studied, investing a lump sum immediately beat spreading it out about two-thirds of the time, because markets rise more often than they fall. It also said dollar-cost averaging can suit people who would otherwise worry or delay, because it limits regret. Check the original paper for exact figures.
How to choose
- Money you receive regularly (a paycheck going into a 401(k)) is invested regularly by default.
- A one-off sum: decide how you would feel if the market fell 10% the week after. If that would make you sell, spreading it may suit you better.
- Keep fees low; many small trades with a fee each can cost more.
See also The November 2026 correction: what is reported, what history shows, what you can do and How long do market falls last? What history shows, and 401(k) match: what it is and why it matters.
You can note each purchase and see the average cost per share in Vartu, which keeps average cost, gain and dividends for each holding on your iPhone with no account.
Related calculators
- Compound interest calculator: how much could your investment grow?
- Stock market recovery calculator: what gain do you need after a fall?
On a computer?
Scan with your iPhone camera to open Vartu in the App Store.
More from the blog
- How long do market falls last? What history shows
- The November 2026 correction: what is reported, what history shows, what you can do
- How to budget when your income is irregular
- What FDIC and NCUA insurance covers, and what it does not
Vartu is not financial advice. Forecasts and estimates are arithmetic on your own figures.