Overpay your mortgage or invest? How to think about the trade-off
A neutral explainer on the maths and the risks behind overpaying a mortgage versus investing the same money.
Many homeowners wonder whether spare cash should go on the mortgage or into investments. There is no single right answer, and this post will not give one. It explains how to compare the two properly, with a worked example using invented numbers, and lists what to check before you overpay.
What overpaying actually does
When you overpay a repayment mortgage, the extra goes against the balance you owe. A smaller balance means less interest charged from then on. Overpaying has the same effect as earning your mortgage rate on that money, with one important feature: the saving is not taxed, and it does not depend on markets. If your rate is 4.5%, then each £1 you overpay avoids interest at 4.5% a year for as long as that rate lasts.
What investing does instead
Investing could earn more than the mortgage rate over a long period, but it might not, and it can lose money, sometimes for years. That uncertainty is the price of the possible extra growth. An investment return is not guaranteed, whereas the interest you avoid on a mortgage is a known number for the term of your deal. That is the heart of the trade-off: a more certain, modest return against an uncertain, possibly higher one.
A worked example (invented numbers)
Take a £200,000 repayment mortgage over 25 years at a fixed 4.5%. The monthly payment is about £1,112, and across 25 years you would pay roughly £333,500 in total. Now overpay £200 a month. The same loan would be paid off in about 19 years and the total paid would be roughly £297,700, so the overpayments save about £35,800 of interest. This ignores rate changes, so it is only an illustration. Over the same period, the £200 a month could have been invested instead. At an assumed 5% annual return (an assumption, not a forecast) £200 a month for 25 years would grow to about £119,000, against £60,000 paid in. At 3% it would be about £89,000, and at 7% about £162,000. The point is the spread: the mortgage route gives a known saving, while the investing route gives a wide range of outcomes, and outcomes below the assumption are possible too. Any comparison like this also depends on fees, tax wrappers and the mortgage rate when your deal ends.
Things that change the answer
- Your mortgage rate. The higher it is, the more attractive the certain saving looks; the lower it is, the more the comparison leans on investment returns.
- Early repayment charges. Many fixed and tracker deals limit how much you can overpay each year without a charge. Check your mortgage documents or ask your lender before sending extra money.
- Your time horizon. Investing is meant for money you will not need for years. A mortgage can be overpaid slowly, but the money is not easy to get back, since it is tied up in the house.
- Liquidity. Cash in a fund or savings account can be used in an emergency; money overpaid on a mortgage generally cannot be taken back, though some lenders offer an offset or drawdown feature. Ask your lender.
- Tax wrappers. Investing inside a stocks and shares ISA or pension keeps growth tax-free; see ISA or pension: where does your first £100 a month go?.
- Your appetite for risk. Some people sleep better with a smaller mortgage; others are fine with market swings.
- Emergency fund first. See How much should you keep in an emergency fund, and where?.
Is it really either/or?
No. Many people split the spare cash, or switch between the two as their mortgage deal changes. Some overpay while the rate is high and invest when it falls; others do the reverse. A split is not a hedge that guarantees anything, but it can reduce the regret of picking the wrong one. Whether you do this is for you to decide.
The emotional side
Numbers are only part of it. A mortgage is the biggest debt most people have, and paying it down can bring peace of mind that an investment return cannot measure. Equally, someone with no investments and a long working life ahead may feel they are leaving growth on the table. Both feelings are legitimate. A useful test is to imagine each choice going badly: the stock market falls 30% after you invest, or interest rates fall and you wish you had kept cash. Which would you find harder to live with?
When your fixed deal ends
The mortgage rate you overpay against is only known until your deal ends. At that point, a new rate is set, and it may be higher or lower. Many people review overpayments at each remortgage date, and some use the weeks before the deal ends to check how much they can overpay penalty-free under the new terms. Treat any plan as a plan for the current deal, not for 25 years.
Common mistakes
- Overpaying beyond the penalty-free limit without checking the charge.
- Draining cash so completely that an emergency pushes you onto a credit card.
- Comparing a mortgage rate with a one-year investment return rather than a long-run range.
- Forgetting that rates change when a fixed deal ends.
- Overlooking an employer pension match, which is often worth considering before either.
What to check before you decide
- The overpayment allowance and any charge in your mortgage terms.
- Whether the extra should reduce the payment or shorten the term, since lenders handle this differently.
- Your mortgage end date and what rate you could get next.
- Whether you have enough in easy-access cash.
- If you are unsure, MoneyHelper or a regulated adviser can talk it through.
Using Vartu to look at the numbers
Vartu keeps spending, investments and net worth in one place, and it has a debt payoff plan (avalanche or snowball). For UK homes it can estimate value from HM Land Registry's index, labelled as an estimate (see Check your house value with the UK House Price Index). The data stays on your iPhone, and one spending and one broker account are free. Try it at App Store. Vartu does not tell you whether to overpay or invest; it just lays out your own numbers.
Related calculators
- Mortgage repayment calculator UK: your monthly payment and what a rate rise does
- Compound interest calculator: how much could your investment grow?
On a computer?
Scan with your iPhone camera to open Vartu in the App Store.
More from the blog
- What does 5 April actually mean for your money?
- ISA or pension: where does your first £100 a month go?
- How much should you keep in an emergency fund, and where?
- UK tax year end (5 April): what to check on your investments
Vartu is not financial advice. Forecasts and estimates are arithmetic on your own figures.